Reader TTS

Twelve days before his retirement, CBI Director Ranjit Sinha today suffered a major blow when the Supreme Court removed him from the 2G scam case, saying the allegations against him of

protecting some accused appears to be "prima facie credible". The apex court, in an unprecedented order, handed over the case to the senior-most officer after Sinha in the 2G scam

investigating team. A bench headed by Chief Justice HL Dattu, however, refused to pass an elaborate order on the issue saying that it would "tarnish" the "image and reputation" of the

premier agency.

The fate of the top cop, who is due to retire on December 2, in the case became abundantly clear when the bench, also comprising justices MB Lokur and AK Sikri, before rising for the lunch

break, asked senior advocate Vikas Singh, appearing for Sinha, about various options. The court said it did not want to pass an elaborate order, because it would be against the interest and

image of the agency. "Prima facie the allegations made in the application(by NGO Centre for Public Interest Litigation) are credible and required to be accepted," the bench observed.

However, his counsel insisted that the allegations levelled against Sinha of scuttling the 2G probe were "untrue". The CBI chief's role was criticised by the apex court- appointed Special

Public Prosecutor Anand Grover and counsel appearing for CBI, K K Venugopal, also raised questions on Sinha naming a senior IPS officer as mole in the team. The apex court also recalled its

earlier order by which it directed the NGO to disclose the name of whistleblower who had provided documents and visitors diary of Sinha's residence.

At the outset, the Special Public Prosecutor raised serious questions on the conduct of the top cop and contended that the whole case against some of the accused would have been "demolished"

if Sinha's instructions had been followed in the trial. Grover said that stand taken by Sinha was "completely inconsistent" with the agency's stand and said he tried to interfere at the

last stage of the trial when the prosecution evidence was almost over.

He said that information that he gathered, after going through all file notings, is "shocking" and cannot be revealed in an open court. The independent prosecutor also raised questions on

the opinion of Law Ministry to allegedly favour some of the firms facing trial in 2G case. "It is a sad story how ministry works. An official deposed saying that it was done on the basis of

file notings of the Minister but the question is who was the person behind the Minister. Its shocking," he said.

At this stage of proceedings, the hearing took a new turn with advocate Prashant Bhushan alleging that CBI counsel in 2G case KK Venugopal was directed by Sinha not to argue in this case. 

The bench then queried who had given such direction. CBI joint Director Ashok Tiwari, who was present in the court room, said that Venugopal continues to be the CBI counsel in the apex court

and also tried to shield his chief in the present controversy.

The court took strong exception to Tiwari trying to defend his boss and also raised question on the presence of around nine senior officers of CBI inside the court room. "You are not agents

of the Director and you cannot be his mouthpiece. You do not need to take responsibility. How is your presence required here," the bench questioned.

"Why so many CBI officers are here. How come so many officers sitting in the court room. We do not require their presence. We are not hearing 2G investigation case. We are hearing an

application filed against the Director," it said. The bench asked the officers to leave the courtroom and "do their duty rather than observing court proceedings". The officers thereafter

left the courtroom. 

Venugopal then brought to court's notice media reports on Singh naming a DIG-rank officer Santosh Rastogi as a "mole" who supplied documents and guest list of Director's residence to

Bhushan. 

The CBI through Venugopal criticised Sinha's stand and urged the court to ask him to withdraw the statement. "Yesterday's statement was not right that the officer is a mole in the CBI. If

there is any evidence then it must be produced. The statement must be withdrawn as the officer needs protection," he said.

Bhushan also submitted that he never met the officer and somebody else had given him the documents and filed an affidavit in this regard which was taken on record.

The bench also raised objection that image of the officer cannot be allowed to be tarnished and said that it was wrong on the part of Sinha's counsel to name the officer while arguing the

case. Going by file notings on transfer of the officer, the bench said, "It seems that you want to clear the path as the officer was opposing some of your decisions".

The bench said the decision taken by the Director to transfer the officer amounts to "overreaching" the apex court order which had directed that no person in 2G probe team be removed without

its order. It said that "all is not well" and "some allegations against him (Sinha) appeared to be prima facie credible and asked Singh about the options available in the case as it did not

want to pass an elaborate order with reasons which would have the potential to tarnish the image and reputation of the premier institution.

Vikas Singh, however, preferred to continue with his arguments saying that statements made by SPP and others against the Director is patently false and baseless. He said that Director's

decision may not be the best but there was no malafide and dishonest intention behind the decision.

The bench, however, brushed aside the contention saying, "For every thing there is justification but the justification should appeal to us".

At the end of the four-hour long proceedings, the bench passed a brief order directing Sinha to keep himself away from the 2G case and "not to interfere in the investigation and trial of the

2G cases and recuse himself from them".

"To protect the faith in the institution and reputation of Director, CBI, we are not focusing on elaborate reasons and it is suffice to say information furnished by applicants prima facie

appears to be credible and therefore required to be accepted," the bench said. 

'Lord Bavuma, It’s time for Africa': Fans react as South Africa beat Australia in WTC 2025 final to end 27-year ICC trophy drought

Anirudh Ravichander breaks silence on his marriage rumours with Kavya Maran, asks fans to...

Meet woman who cleared IIT, NIMHANS, UGC-NET, all without any coaching classes, is now set to join...

WTC 2025 Final Prize Money: Australia walk away with Rs 186300000, winners South Africa get....

Meet man who did B.Tech from BHU, masters from US, still faced 400 job rejections, is now CEO of company worth Rs 10.86 lakh crore, name is..

Pizza from a vending machine? Japan’s latest food innovation goes viral

Will Israel-Iran conflict affect oil prices in India? Fuel rates to…

'You are so weak': HR sparks backlash after insulting woman seeking leave for fever

IAS officer Athar Aamir was once married to UPSC topper Tina Dabi, they got divorced, his second wife is..., she is from...

SA vs AUS, WTC Final 2025: South Africa create history, end 27-year ICC title drought with 5-wicket win over Australia

Anderson-Tendulkar trophy launch postponed ahead of India-England Test series due to THIS reason

Madhya Pradesh: Bhopal bridge's 'deadly' 90 degree turn goes viral, netizens say, 'Death will arrive...'

Delhi-NCR Weather: Yellow alert for Delhi as IMD predicts rain, thunderstorms for next..., check 7-day forecast here

Meet woman, mother of billionaire businessmen, a Veena maestro who started flower shop with just Rs 500, now runs…, her name is..

'Where does instinct come from?': Baby alligator’s notorious death roll leaves internet stunned, WATCH viral video

Ahead of India-England Test series, BCCI requests ECB to rethink over renaming....

The 11A mystery: Survivor from deadly 1998 crash had same seat number as Air India tragedy's lone survivor, is it the safest seat?

Mark Zuckerberg's Meta AI is exposing your personal searches, private chats to public, here's how you can prevent it

India's strong response to US after it hails Pakistan for its 'fight against terrorism', reminds Washington of Osama Bin Laden: 'None of us has...'

42-year-old James Anderson returns with career-best figures on T20 comeback, reflects on a decade of missed chances

Internet is abuzz with ‘Pentagon Pizza Index’ viral theory, does it has connection with Israel Iran conflict?

Bipasha Basu SLAMS trolls body-shaming her after child's birth, calls memes 'deeply disturbing reflections' of society: 'Hope human race does not..'

This company gives stern warning to its employees, says come to office for…, or quit job, not Mukesh Ambani's Reliance Industries, Ratan Tata's TCS, Narayan Murthy's Infosys, it is...

Israel-Iran War: Israel defence minister's BIG warning to Iran, says 'Tehran will burn if...'

Meet man, actor turned director, who once urinated on Salman Khan's shoes, hit him with spoon and plate, got slapped but..., his name is..

‘Throwing away brownie, body shaming, allegations of...’:Telugu actor Kalpika Ganesh lands herself in trouble, here’s what happened

Karan Veer Mehra pens emotional note on Sushant Singh Rajput's death anniversary: 'You pushed me…'

'Enough disrespect': Bal Krishna gets glam makeover at Haryana salon, viral video sparks mixed reactions

Amid conflict with Iran, Israel's military issues apology to India for THIS reason, says, 'fails to..'

This actress once called Amitabh Bachchan at 2 am to ask if he is okay, Big B got admitted to ICU next day due to..., her name is..

PM Modi to attend G7 Summit in Canada, travel to Cyprus, meet leaders in Croatia from...

'Glorious legacy reduced to...': Congress lashes out at Union government for abstaining from UNGA proposal on Gaza ceasefire

Meet Krishang Joshi, NEET UG 2025 topper with AIR 3, got 99.9999095 percentile, he is from...

Meet Mrinal Kumar Jha, who cracked NEET UG 2025 exam with 99.9998189 percentile, his AIR is..., he is from...

'I would never fly Air India again': David Warner vows to never fly with airline after Ahmedabad crash

Meet Utkarsh Awadhiya, NEET UG 2025 topper with AIR 2, his percentile is..., he is from...

Sharing drink turns costly: Man wakes up to missing phone, cash worth Rs 18,000,... after metro ride home

Meet Avika Aggarwal, NEET UG 2025 female topper, who secured 99.9996832 percentile, her AIR is..., she is from...

'Jackie Shroff flirted with my mother': Siddharth Nigam says Housefull 5 actor called his mom, said 'hi darling, aaj tu...'

Karisma Kapoor's ex-husband Sunjay Kapur's last words revealed, said this to people present at polo match before tragic death

Viral Video: Faf du Plessis pulls off one-handed blinder against MI New York in Major League Cricket 2025

Meet Mahesh Kumar, NEET UG 2025 topper with 99.9999547 percentile, secured AIR 1, he is from...

'Meri ek kiss ne...': Dharmendra talks about his kissing scene with Shabana Azmi, calls it…

India vs India A Match: Shubman Gill's captaincy journey kicks off with powerful knock, KL Rahul shines with fifty on day 1, watch here

NEET UG Result 2025 DECLARED at neet.nta.nic.in; direct link, list of toppers here

Viral video: Woman's dance for Instagram reel takes an unexpected turn as horse kicks her, netizens say 'dance pasand nahi aaya'

Who is Major General Amir Hatami? Iran's newly appointed Chief Commander of the Army amid Attacks from Israel

After multiple delays, Indian astronaut Shubhanshu Shukla's Axiom-4 mission to launch on...

Meet woman who starred in two famous Bollywood movies, worked with Isha Ambani, Shah Rukh Khan, is director of…, name is...

Meet man who failed 35 exams, cracked UPSC exam twice, first became IPS officer with AIR... then left after few months due to…

'Bunny Hop' catches to become illegal soon? Check what new MCC law says about boundary catch

Meet girl who has world’s most beautiful handwriting, she is not from India, US, UK, Europe, Pakistan, China, Japan, but..., her name is..

Meet Leanna Mallya, daughter of Vijay Mallya, lesser-known sister of Sidharth Mallya and Tanya Mallya, she is currently working as..., her net worth is Rs...

Vijay Mallya's Kingfisher Villa, once venue for luxurious parties, is now owned by this Bollywood couple, they are..., its now called..

Watch: Kids caught stealing nuts and bolts from Bihar's Rs 422 crore Patna flyover in viral video, netizens says, 'kuch din aur...'

F-15I Raam, F-16I Soufa and F-35I Adir: Details of Israel’s military aircraft that destroyed Iran’s nuclear facilities

Qaseem Basir: Iran’s most advanced missile could rival US THAAD, challenge Israel’s Defenses, named after....

Karisma Kapoor's ex-husband Sunjay Kapur's funeral in Delhi might face delay due to...

Mukesh Ambani and Nita Ambani's son Anant Ambani takes big decision, decides to donate..., meets...

AUS vs SA: Will rain stand between South Africa and WTC 2025 title on Day 4?

Net worth of Rs 78000 crores, still no one knows his name, works closely with Mukesh Ambani, Isha Ambani, owns Rs 250000 crore brand, he is..

SRH owner Kavya Maran may marry THIS man, who once dated famous actress, is also connected to Rajinikanth, name is...

This Chennai based startup gifts employees increment, brand new SUVs due to..., its business is....

Iran retaliates with over 100 missiles, 170 drones, is Israel ready for the full-scale onslaught? How powerful is Iran’s Defense Force?

Yashasvi Jaiswal's childhood coach makes big claims ahead of Headingley Test, says 'when he decides something'

When Sushant Singh Rajput quit his dreams for Bollywood, rejected Stanford University scholarship, became SRK fan, then died tragically: 'I wanted to...'

Weather update: Delhi-NCR sizzles under intense heatwave, IMD predicts rain, thunderstorm on...

Google CEO Sundar Pichai Vs Apple CEO Tim Cook: Who gets highest salary? The answer is...

Nita Ambani's MI team picks THIS star cricketer for Rs..., son of famous Bollywood director, he is...

NEET UG 2025 Result BIG Update: NTA NEET UG Final Answer Key released at neet.nta.nic.in, result to be declared on...

Viral video: Foreign woman names her daughter 'India', due to this REASON, Internet reacts, watch

This Muslim nation is the world’s oldest country, people have been living here for over 1 lakh years, India stands at...

Meet man who faced 150 rejections later turned it into Rs 65,0000 crore company famous as India’s... bought house near Mukesh Ambani's Antilia, net worth is...

Celina Jaitley recalls Air India crew's kindness after tragic Ahmedabad plane crash: 'Never let your class...'

'Didi sharma gayi': RJ Mahvash blushes as paps tease her about Yuzvendra Chahal, fans react, watch

Meet woman, auto driver's daughter, who cracked UPSC exam with AIR..., set to become first Muslim woman from Maharashtra to...

Raj Kundra says 'I can't lie to save my...' after he exits The Traitors: ‘My wife is...'

This is most expensive hotel in Uttar Pradesh, its luxury suite costs over Rs 10 lakh per night, it is located in...

Mohammad Rizwan, Babar Azam, Shaheen Afridi's T20I careers over? Ignored for Pakistan's tours of...

'Baton not passed but thrown...': Yograj Singh rips into Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma for untimely Test retirements; namedrops Yuvraj Singh

World’s Largest Banks 2025: THIS bank retains no. 1 spot for third year in row, check top rankings

Pilot Sumeet Sabharwal’s last words to ailing father before Air India tragedy: ‘I will quit flying to take care for you’

Brother recalls last words to sister before Air India crash: 'Gave her a hug, asked to take care'

Meet IPS officer, scored just 57 per cent in Class 10, expelled from school, later studied from JNU, cracked UPSC exam with AIR..., he is...

'Threats were made to burn down theatres screening Thug Life': Supreme Court issues notice to Karnataka on plea seeking release of Kamal Haasan film

What caused Ahmedabad plane crash? Experts weigh in on possible reasons behind Air India tragedy

Why did Google start Doodles? 7 lesser-known facts about Google Doodles we bet you didn't know

Housefull 5 box office collection day 8: Akshay Kumar film is unstoppable, crosses Rs 200 crore-mark worldwide

Prabhas' The Raja Saab teaser leaked online, makers issue warning: 'Will be suspended immediately if...'

SA vs AUS WTC Final: Aiden Markram joins Steve Smith, Travis Head in elite list; becomes third batter to achieve THIS rare feat

DNA TV Show: Will Boeing aircraft be banned in India after Ahmedabad tragedy?

Study says these are world's most dangerous countries for travelers in 2025, safest is...

Viral Video: Woman's flawless belly-dancing to Piya Tu Ab Toh Aaja impresses Priyanka Chopra, netizens say, 'no one can...', WATCH

Gaurav Taneja aka Flying Beast breaks down Air India crash in Ahmedabad, says 'looks Like..., pilot had no...'

Not Amitabh Bachchan, this actor was first choice for Sholay; Dharmendra then convinced Ramesh Sippy to replace him with Big B, he is...

SHOCKING: Scientists discover mysterious 6000-year-old human DNA in..., holds unique...

What did transpire between Benjamin Netanyahu and Narendra Modi when Israeli PM dialed New Delhi? MEA says...

Astrologer faces backlash for linking old prediction to Air India crash in Ahmedabad: 'Astrology is not fate...'

WTC Final: Steve Smith leaves field with dislocated finger during SA vs AUS summit clash at Lord's

Ahmedabad Plane Crash: Tata Group chairman N Chandrasekaran's emotional message to employees, 'To lose a single person...'