Difference between assertion, evidence

Difference between assertion, evidence


Play all audios:


AdCommentNational OpinionCommentNational OpinionNews HomeGood afternoon, Your ContentNewslettersMy saved ListAccountMy AccountLogoutNewsSportCommunityTributes & FuneralsClassifiedsExplore


TravelEntertainmentLifestyleRecommendedQuick LinksToday’s PaperDownload our appInteractive PuzzlesViewJobsNetworkVideoView real estatePress Releases from AAPContact usHelp CentrePrivacy


PolicyAbout usView Subscription OffersThe Examiner's complete view of propertyHome/Comment/National OpinionDifference between assertion, evidenceBy Katrena StephensonMarch 25 2018 - 9:02amBy


Katrena StephensonMarch 25 2018 - 9:02amFacebookTwitterWhatsappEmailCopyDifference between assertion, evidence I admit I get frustrated by statements such as those made by the Tasmanian


Chamber of Commerce and Industry this week, that taking planning away from local government will resolve all and any issues. 


Subscribe now for unlimited access. Login or signup to continue reading


50% off EOFY SaleAll articles from our website & appThe digital version of Today's PaperCrosswords, Sudoku and TriviaAll other regional websites in your areaContinue I find all too often


such assertions are not backed by evidence and reflect a lack of practical understanding of how land use planning regulations, determined by state government, must be applied locally.


At the recent housing summit, I noted the evidence simply does not support assertions that current processing timelines for council planning applications contribute to the housing shortage.


In fact, average development applications timelines are in line with statutory requirements. 


I also noted this data is collected annually by the state government, is publicly available and yet was unknown by most at the summit, including those making commentary on planning.


What would be more useful than unsubstantiated rhetoric, is examples of where things are not working, which can then be worked through by experts, to understand what is truly impacting on a


development progressing.


When the red tape reduction coordinator presented to a Local Government Association of Tasmania meeting in 2016, it was noted that there had been few examples identified that sat within the


direct sphere of influence of local government.


In fact, the recommendations developed following extensive industry consultation related to legislation and policy within the state government’s control.


A single body for managing planning will not automatically lead to sustainable development that respects our built and environmental heritage values.


To reflect our communities’ values, there is a need to engage with community.


As the level of government closest to communities, councils are well placed to engage locally and do so efficiently on a daily basis.


Local government has been working hard to implement the continuous planning reform agendas of successive state governments, including the current Tasmanian planning scheme.


However, in the absence of other key requirements, such as the development of strategic planning policies and the promised review of the residential planning provisions, the Tasmanian


planning scheme does little to shape our environments or effect planning process efficiency.


The time has come for less unsubstantiated rhetoric and more evidence.


An evidence-based approach is vital when it comes to planning and other key aspects of local government service delivery, including the proposed takeover of TasWater.


By reviewing the submissions and transcripts for the Legislative Council committee into the takeover of TasWater, it is clear the evidence was just not there to back the claims of what could


be achieved through a change in ownership.


It is time to shift dialogue about local government.


Tasmania’s councils are modernising and emerging as lean, collaborative and accountable to their communities.


Local government is always open to improvement but let’s start an improvement dialogue from an evidence base.


Let’s be strategic and develop a clear understanding of the current and future role of councils in our communities and how this can positively impact Tasmania as a whole. 


Katrena Stephenson is the chief executive of LGAT.ShareFacebookTwitterWhatsappEmailCopyMore from National OpinionWhy the Liberals may hold - or even gain ground in Tasmania at the electionNo


commentsAmericans might have ceded government to corrupt oligarchs, but not AustraliansNo commentsAny time someone tries to get ahead in Australia, the govt taxes them to the hiltNo


commentsThis deal was bad from the start. Now is our chance to get outNo commentsSydney, I loved you but now I see what you really areRoundtables aren't really necessary. But productivity


serves a higher purpose for ChalmersNo commentsNewsletters & AlertsView all Daily


Your morning news Today's top stories curated by our news team. Also includes evening update.


Loading... Weekdays


The lunch break Grab a quick bite of today's latest news from around the region and the nation.


Loading... Weekdays


The evening wrap Catch up on the news of the day and unwind with great reading for your evening.


Loading... Weekly


Subscriber OnlyNote from the Editor Get the editor's insights: what's happening & why it matters.


Loading... Weekly


Subscriber OnlyFootyHQ Love footy? We've got all the action covered.


Loading... Weekly


Sport The latest news, results & expert analysis.


Loading... Weekly


Explore Travel Every Saturday and Tuesday, explore destinations deals, tips & travel writing to transport you around the globe.


Loading... Weekdays


The Echidna Sharp. Close to the ground. Digging deep. Your weekday morning newsletter on national affairs, politics and more.


Loading... Twice weekly


The Informer Your essential national news digest: all the big issues on Wednesday and great reading every Saturday.


Loading... Twice weekly


Voice of Real Australia Get real, Australia! Let the ACM network's editors and journalists bring you news and views from all over.


Loading... As it happens


Subscriber OnlySpecial Reports Get the very best journalism from The Examiner by signing up to our special reports.


Loading... Weekly


Motoring Get news, reviews and expert insights every Thursday from CarExpert, ACM's exclusive motoring partner.


Loading... As it happens


Breaking news alert Be the first to know when news breaks.


Loading... Daily


Subscriber OnlyToday's Paper Alert Your digital replica of Today's Paper. Ready to read from 5am!


Loading... Daily


Subscriber OnlyYour favourite puzzles Test your skills with interactive crosswords, sudoku & trivia. Fresh daily!


Loading... Advertisement


Ad Advertisement


AdAustralian Community MediaACM WebsiteConditions of UsePrivacyTerms and Conditions - Digital SubscriptionTerms and Conditions - Newspaper SubscriptionThe ExaminerContactAbout UsWorking With


UsToday's PaperCommenting GuidelinesView Property EditionHelp CentreOur SitesViewExploreView InsuranceBeevoPlace an AdClassifiedsCarsTributes & FuneralsCelebrationsPromo


CodesAgTraderMeHelpFarmer's FinanceGarage SalesSubmitSend a letter to the EditorSend Us Your News