Reader TTS

ABSTRACT Populations of the insect-pollinated geophytes _Narcissus assoanus_ and _N. dubius_ (Amaryllidaceae) are commonly dimorphic for stigma height. An extensive survey of populations of

the two species in SW France revealed a wide range of style-morph frequencies, particularly populations with significantly more long-styled than short-styled plants. Here we employ

experimental and theoretical approaches to investigate potential selective mechanisms governing the variation in style-morph frequencies. Controlled pollination of both species demonstrated

that _N. assoanus_ is moderately self-sterile whereas _N. dubius_ is highly self-compatible. Both intra- and intermorph crosses of _N. assoanus_ were equally fertile, indicating that the

species does not exhibit heteromorphic incompatibility. Estimates of female fertility (fruit- and seed-set) and multilocus estimates of outcrossing using allozyme markers provided no

evidence of morph-specific differences in maternal components of reproductive success in natural populations of the two species. This result suggested that differences between the morphs in

male fertility may be largely responsible for the observed morph-ratio variation. To investigate this hypothesis we developed a mating model that incorporates the genetics of stigma-height

dimorphism and contrasting rates of assortative and disassortative mating in the style morphs. Simulation results demonstrated that stigma-height dimorphism will always be maintained when

levels of disassortative mating are greater than assortative mating, and that the observed L-biased populations in _Narcissus_ spp. probably result from greater levels of assortative mating

in this morph in comparison with the S-morph. SIMILAR CONTENT BEING VIEWED BY OTHERS WITHIN-INDIVIDUAL PHENOTYPIC PLASTICITY IN FLOWERS FOSTERS POLLINATION NICHE SHIFT Article Open access 11

August 2020 ISLAND PLANTS WITH NEWLY DISCOVERED REPRODUCTIVE TRAITS HAVE HIGHER CAPACITY FOR UNIPARENTAL REPRODUCTION, SUPPORTING BAKER’S LAW Article Open access 18 May 2024 CONVERGENT

EVOLUTIONARY PATTERNS OF HETEROSTYLY ACROSS ANGIOSPERMS SUPPORT THE POLLINATION-PRECISION HYPOTHESIS Article Open access 09 February 2024 INTRODUCTION In the earlier paper of this pair

(Baker et al., 2000), we described an unusual plant sexual polymorphism in which populations of _Narcissus_ spp. (Amaryllidaceae), a genus of insect-pollinated geophytes native to the

Mediterranean Basin, are dimorphic for style length. Most populations of _N. assoanus_ and _N. dubius_ in SW France consist of two floral morphs, one in which the stigma is at the same level

as the stamens or protrudes beyond them (long-styled or L-morph) and the other in which the stigma is located well below the stamens (short-styled or S-morph). The polymorphism occurs in at

least a dozen _Narcissus_ species distributed across three sections of the genus (Barrett et al., 1996). Stigma-height dimorphism is distinct from the well-known heterostylous condition

distyly (Darwin, 1877; Barrett, 1992), because stamen levels in the two floral morphs are positioned similarly, rather than showing a reciprocal correspondence with the two stigma heights.

In addition, unlike most heterostylous species, the two floral morphs in _Narcissus_ spp. do not differ in pollen size or pollen production. Although _N. assoanus_ and _N. dubius_ show

similar patterns of sex-organ deployment within flowers, population surveys in SW France revealed that the two species differ in the frequencies of style-morphs that occur within populations

(Baker et al., 2000). In _N. assoanus_ style-morph ratios ranged from isoplethy (1L:1S) to L-biased, depending on population size. Large populations were always isoplethic, whereas smaller

populations exhibited variable style-morph frequencies, particularly L-biased ratios. In contrast, populations of _N. dubius_ were either strongly L-biased or monomorphic for the L-morph. Of

the 67 populations of the two species that were surveyed none was S-biased or contained only this morph. Similar patterns of style-morph frequency variation have also been reported in other

dimorphic species of _Narcissus_ with L-biased populations and L-monomorphy most commonly occurring (Arroyo & Dafni, 1995; Barrett et al., 1996). In this paper we consider the

maintenance of stigma-height dimorphism in _Narcissus_ and investigate likely selective mechanisms that might account for the unusual patterns of morph-frequency variation observed in _N.

assoanus_ and _N. dubius_. We begin by determining the compatibility status of the two species through controlled pollination and then examine the possibility that morph-specific differences

in maternal fitness of the style morphs could potentially lead to biased morph ratios. We compare estimates of the female fertility of style-morphs in natural populations by examining

patterns of fruit- and seed-set. Style-morph ratios can also be influenced by morph-specific differences in mating patterns and an extensive literature on this topic is available for

heterostylous plants (e.g. Crosby, 1949; Bodmer, 1960; Ganders, 1975; Charlesworth & Charlesworth, 1979; Barrett et al., 1987, 1989). We measure outcrossing rates in natural populations

to determine whether morph-specific differences in floral morphology within each species might be associated with different patterns of mating. Finally, we develop a mating model to

investigate how variation in levels of assortative and disassortative mating between the style morphs might influence their frequency within populations. In particular, we were interested in

exploring the possibility that differences in assortative mating between style morphs caused by their differing sex-organ positions could explain the L-biased morph ratios that are typical

of many _Narcissus_ populations. MATERIALS AND METHODS All experimental studies described below were conducted from 1996 to 1998 on populations of _N. assoanus_ and _N. dubius_ occurring

within 50 km of Montpellier, SW France. See figs 4 and 5 in Baker et al. (2000) for the general location of populations. COMPATIBILITY STATUS We transplanted plants of the L- and S-morph of

each _Narcissus_ species to a pollinator-free glasshouse at CNRS, Montpellier, for hand-pollination to determine their compatibility status. It was particularly important to determine

whether the species are self-sterile, and, if so, whether stylar dimorphism is associated with an intramorph incompatibility system typical of distylous plants. In _N. assoanus_, we

conducted crosses over two years using three populations (St-Mathieu-de-Tréviers in 1996, and Bancel and Ceyrac in 1997). In _N. dubius_, it was difficult to find a substantial number of

plants of the S-morph, even in large dimorphic populations. Thus, in _N. dubius_ we performed the crossing programme in only one population in 1998. In both species, the treatments were: (i)

intramorph pollination; (ii) intermorph pollination; (iii) self-pollination; and (iv) no hand-pollination to detect the capability for autonomous selfing. All cross-pollinations involved a

single, randomly chosen pollen donor. In both style morphs, we removed anthers from flowers prior to dehiscence and examined stigmas using a 16× hand lens to ensure that no self pollen was

present before hand-pollination. It was necessary to slit open part of the floral tube to pollinate the S-morph, so flowers of both morphs were opened in the same manner. We collected mature

fruits 6–8 weeks after pollination, counted the number of plump, filled seeds and flake-like ovules, and estimated total ovule number of flowers. We analysed seed-set data from experimental

pollinations by analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) in JMP (SAS, 1994) using total ovule number as a covariate. Only capsules that produced seed were included in the analysis. In _N. assoanus_,

we examined the effects of style morph, pollination type (self-, intermorph and intramorph), population, and their interactions. Three-way interaction terms were backwards eliminated from

the analyses if they did not have a significant effect on the mean number of seeds set (i.e. _P_ > 0.05; cf. Sokal & Rohlf, 1995). We performed contrasts to compare self vs.

outcrossed and intramorph vs. intermorph seed-set; and logistic regression to examine the effects of the above variables on mean fruit-set. We employed a similar approach in analysing seed-

and fruit-set data in _N. dubius_. We used ANCOVA to examine the effects of style morph, pollination type and their interaction on mean seed-set. We performed contrasts as above and logistic

regression to analyse the mean proportion of fruit-set. FEMALE FERTILITY IN NATURAL POPULATIONS We measured seed-set of tagged L- and S-styled plants in six dimorphic _N. assoanus_

populations in 1996 [Bancel (Ban), Col Hortus (Col), Hortus Mountain (Hmt), Pont sur Brestalou (Psb), Rigalderie (Rig) and St-Bauzille-de-Montmel (StB)], and both seed- and fruit-set in four

populations in 1997 [Col, Psb, StB and Aguzan (Agu)]. Seed-set was measured in _N. dubius_ for 1996 and 1998. In 1996, we sampled three populations exhibiting stigma-height dimorphism [La

Clause (Clau), Hortus Mountain (Hmt), and St-Bauzille-de-Montmel (StB)] and two populations monomorphic for the L-morph [La Baune (Bau) and Pont du Gard (PdG)]. In 1998, we measured both

fruit- and seed-set in a subset of these populations: Clau, StB and PdG. In _N. assoanus_, we analysed seed-set data for both years using a mixed-model ANCOVA with total ovule number as the

covariate. Random effects included year sampled and population nested within year. Style morph was treated as a fixed effect. Interaction terms in the model included morph by year and morph

by population (nested within year). We analysed fruit-set data for 1997 using logistic regression. The two-way model examined the effects of morph, population and their interaction on

fruit-set. In _N. dubius_, we analysed seed-set over the two years using a nested design. Effects included sampling year, population nested within year, and morph nested within population

and year. Total ovule number was used as a covariate. We analysed the 1998 fruit-set data using logistic regression and examined the effects of population and morph nested within population

on proportion of fruit set. MATING PATTERNS We performed horizontal starch gel electrophoresis on open-pollinated seeds from six populations of _N. assoanus_ (Ban, Col, Hmt, Psb, Rig, StB)

and three populations of _N. dubius_ (Clau, Hmt, StB), following the methods of Shore & Barrett (1987) and Wendel & Weeden (1989). All populations were dimorphic for style length.

Electrophoresis was also performed on seed families from two monomorphic _N. dubius_ populations (Bau, PdG). We initially screened all populations for 18 enzyme systems: from these, six

polymorphic enzyme systems (_Adh_, _Gdh_, _Idh_, _Got_, _Pgi_, _Tpi_) were reliably resolved in _N. assoanus_ and two (_Acp_, _Pgm_) in _N. dubius_. We used Ritland’s MLTR program (Ritland,

1990) to estimate morph-specific outcrossing rates. Outcrossing rates (_t̂_) and their standard deviations (based on 1000 bootstrap valves) were estimated from approximately 20 seed families

per morph (range 15–21) for a given population. For each seed family, eight individual seeds were genotyped. Ritland’s MLTR program assumes that allele frequencies do not differ

significantly between groups, implying that mating is random with respect to morph (i.e. no disassortative mating between morphs). However, this seems highly unlikely given the 1:1 morph

ratios of some populations which imply significant disassortative mating (Baker et al., 2000). If this assumption is violated, there will be a downward bias in _t̂_ when a common pollen pool

is used to estimate the outcrossing rate rather than a separate pollen pool. Because trial runs indicated that there was a significant difference in allele frequencies between the morphs at

some loci in all populations, outcrossing rates were estimated using separate pollen pools (and see Eckert & Barrett, 1994). Differences in outcrossing rate between the style morphs in

dimorphic populations were assessed by pairwise comparisons of bootstrap estimates following the method of Eckert & Barrett (1994). With this approach, morphs were considered to differ

significantly if 100(1 − αPC/2) percentage of the differences between paired bootstrap values were either all greater than zero or all less than zero (note that αPC represents the type-I

error rate per contrast). Differences in _t̂_ between populations were evaluated in a similar manner: 1000 average estimates of outcrossing were calculated for each population by calculating

the average of the L- and S-morph _t̂_ for a given bootstrap and two populations were considered to differ significantly if, as above, 100(1 − αPC/2) percentage of the differences between

paired bootstraps were either all greater than zero or all less than zero. A GENETIC MATING MODEL We developed a computer model to calculate equilibrium genotype and phenotype frequencies

given varying levels of morph-specific assortative and disassortative mating. The explicit inclusion of assortative mating distinguishes this model from earlier mating models of

heterostylous populations (e.g. Charlesworth, 1979; Heuch, 1979). Table 1 is a matrix the elements of which are the expected proportions of progeny genotypes from all matings for each

maternal genotype. In our model, we assumed that the genetic control of stigma-height dimorphism is a single diallelic locus with the L-morph homozygous recessive (_ss_) and the S-morph _Ss_

or _SS_, as reported for _Narcissus tazetta_ (Dulberger, 1964 and unpubl. data). In each morph, matings were either assortative (within-morph) or disassortative (between-morph); for example

in Table 1, _aS_ represents the proportion of matings between S-plants (assortative) and _dS_ represents the proportion of matings in which a maternal S-plant is pollinated by pollen from a

plant of the L-morph (disassortative). We do not explicitly incorporate the rate of self-fertilization into our model because selfing can be considered genetically equivalent to assortative

mating (i.e. the genotypes of selfed progeny are the same as progeny resulting from assortative mating). In the model, we assumed initial genotype frequencies of 1_ss_ (long):1_Ss_ (short).

Previous studies have not found short-styled _SS_ individuals in natural populations of species with a stigma-height dimorphism (see discussion in Baker et al., 2000). In addition, large,

presumably equilibrium populations of _N. assoanus_ have equal frequencies of the two style morphs so we were interested to examine how variable mating patterns might change morph

frequencies from this equilibrium. Calculations were run in which mating varied from complete disassortative mating (_S_=_aL_=0) to relatively high assortative mating (_aS/dS_=_aL/dL_=2) and

genotype and phenotype frequencies were followed. Each set of calculations was run until an equilibrium in genotype frequency was reached (i.e. the per generation change in progeny genotype

frequency was less than 0.0001). Results of the calculations were plotted in three-dimensions to illustrate the relationship between morph-specific mating in the L- and S-morphs and

genotype frequency at equilibrium. RESULTS COMPATIBILITY RELATIONSHIPS Controlled self- and cross-pollination indicates that _N. assoanus_ is moderately self-sterile whereas _N. dubius_ is

highly self-compatible (Fig. 1). The similar levels of seed-set obtained following intra- and intermorph crosses in _N. assoanus_ demonstrate that this species does not possess a

heteromorphic incompatibility system. In _N. assoanus_, self-pollinations resulted in significantly fewer seed than intra- and intermorph cross-pollination in each of the three populations

examined (grand mean seed-set: self=8.32, SE=0.82, _n_=57; intramorph=21.36, SE=1.32, _n_=74; intermorph= 18.18, SE=1.32, _n_=74). The results of paired contrasts indicated a significant

difference in seed-set between self vs. outcross pollinations but not between the seed-set of intramorph vs. intermorph crosses (Table 2). Fruit-set in _N. assoanus_ showed a similar pattern

to the results obtained for seed-set. Mean fruit-set differed significantly between pollination treatments (χ22=16.89, _P_ < 0.001) with higher fruit-set in outcrossed pollination

(mean=77.9%, SE=4.3, _n_=95 for both intra- and intermorph pollination) compared with self-pollination (mean=55.9%, SE=4.9, _n_=102). Plants of neither morph set seed autonomously (_n_=8 for

each morph in the St-Mathieu-de-Tréviers population) and this treatment was not included in the ANCOVA. An interesting feature of the compatibility data in _N. assoanus_ is the significant

effect of style morph on the number of seeds produced (Fig. 1; Table 2). Long-styled plants had significantly lower seed-set than S-plants and this pattern was consistent across all

populations examined. Fruit-set was also reduced in the L-morph (mean=57.9%, SE= 4.0, _n_=152) when compared to the S-morph (mean= 83.6%, SE=3.1, _n_=140; χ21=17.51, _P_ < 0.001). There

were no significant differences in seed-set between self-, intramorph and intermorph pollination of _N. dubius_ (self=14.29, SE=1.48, _n_=38; intramorph=18.37, SE=1.74, _n_=38;

intermorph=17.07, SE=1.38, _n_=41; Fig. 1, Table 3) and mean fruit-set was consistently high across all pollination types (self=84.4%, SE=5.5, _n_=45; intermorph=93.2%, SE=3.8, _n_=44;

intramorph=88.4%, SE=4.9, _n_=43). There were no significant effects of pollination type, morph, or their interaction on fruit-set (χ25=3.64, _P_=0.6022). Unlike _N. assoanus_, there was no

significant difference in seed-set between the style morphs in response to the pollination treatments (Fig. 1, Table 2). In spite of the lack of self-incompatibility, plants of _N. dubius_

do not set fruit autonomously (_n_=17 and 4, respectively, for L- and S-styled plants). NATURAL FERTILITY Comparisons of fruit- and seed-set of the L- and S-morphs in populations of _N.

assoanus_ and _N. dubius_ failed to detect any general morph-specific effects. In only one of the 18 paired comparisons (_N. dubius_-StB-1996) was there a significant difference in the

fertility of the style morphs (Fig. 2). In _N. assoanus_, mean seed-set varied significantly between years (1996=23.38, SE=0.65, _n_=458; 1997=13.92, SE=1.17, _n_=184; _F_1,555=34.62,

_P_=0.0138) but style morph and population (nested within year) had no effect on mean seed-set (_P_ > 0.13 in both cases). Fruit-set data were only available for populations sampled in

1997. Analysis of these data indicated no effect of style morph, population, or their interaction (χ27=9.09, _P_=0.2463). In _N. dubius_ populations, style morph (nested within population

and year) had a significant influence on seed-set (_F_5,310=3.25, _P_=0.0071). This effect was largely caused by the results from population StB in 1996 (L-morph=27.78, SE=1.96, _n_=35;

S-morph=16.52, SE=4.32, _n_=7; contrast _t_5=3.93, _P_=0.0001). However, when we performed contrasts to compare seed-set between the style morphs in each dimorphic population, no other

significant differences were evident (Clau in 1996 and 1998, Hmt in 1996, and StB in 1998; _P_ > 0.56 for all contrasts). Population nested within year also had a significant effect on

mean seed-set (_F_6,310=3.03, _P_=0.0067), although there was no significant difference in mean seed-set between years (_F_1,310=0.03, _P_=0.8659). Fruit-set data were only available for

populations sampled in 1998. There was no evidence for morph-specific differences in mean fruit-set (L-morph=87.02%, SE=3.00, _n_=75; S-morph= 79.29, SE=6.71%, _n_=19) or of differences in

fruit-set between populations (χ24=6.25, _P_=0.1809). MATING PATTERNS OF STYLE MORPHS IN NATURAL POPULATIONS Comparisons of outcrossing rate in _N. assoanus_ and _N. dubius_ populations

failed to detect significant differences between the L- and S-morphs (Fig. 3). In no case were all pairwise comparisons of morph-specific bootstrap values above or below zero. Populations of

_N. assoanus_ and _N. dubius_ exhibited contrasting mating systems. _Narcissus assoanus_ is highly outcrossing (mean _t̂_: L-morph=0.997, SD=0.0038; S-morph=0.999, SD=0.0014), whereas _N.

dubius_ exhibits a mixed mating system (mean _t̂_ in dimorphic populations: L-morph= 0.579, SD=0.071; S-morph =0.653, SD=0.099). The larger variances in _t̂_ values obtained for populations

of _N. dubius_ compared with _N. assoanus_ (Fig. 3) undoubtedly result, in part, from the small number of allozyme loci available for these estimates (two loci in _N. dubius_ and six loci in

_N. assoanus_). Comparisons of _t̂_ among _N. assoanus_ populations indicated no significant differences. Only one of the pairwise comparisons among _N. dubius_ populations was significant:

_t̂_ in the monomorphic PdG population was significantly lower than in the dimorphic Hmt population (PDG mean _t̂_=0396, SD=0.085; Hmt mean _t̂_=0.735, SD=0.077). EFFECTS OF ASSORTATIVE AND

DISASSORTATIVE MATING ON STYLE-MORPH FREQUENCIES The results of computer calculations on the effects of assortative and disassortative mating on style-morph frequencies are illustrated in

Fig. 4. With complete disassortative mating (_aS/dS_=_aL/dL_=0) equilibrium morph ratios in a population were 1L:1S (Fig. 4a,b) and all individuals of the S-morph were heterozygous at the

locus controlling style length. Stylar dimorphism was maintained when disassortative mating occurred more frequently than assortative mating and the rate of disassortative mating was

equivalent among the morphs (_aL/dL_ and _aS/dS_ < 1; Fig. 4a). When these conditions were met, morph ratios did not differ from 1L:1S and the genotype of the S-morph was primarily _Ss_

(Fig. 4b), although the frequency of the _SS_ genotype increased as assortative mating in plants of the S-morph (_aS_) increased (Fig. 4c). The computer calculations indicated when L-biased

morph ratios would occur. When assortative mating was low in the S-morph (_aS/dS_ < 0.8) but intermediate in frequency in the L-morph (_aL/dL_=0.8–1.2), equilibrium morph ratios were

biased towards the L-morph and populations became fixed for this morph if the proportion of assortative matings in the L-morph increased (Fig. 4a). At very high levels of _aS_ or _aL_,

populations became fixed for the S- or L-morph, respectively. This is because assortative mating in the S-morph results in the segregation of the _SS_ genotype and assortative mating in the

L-morph results only in L-styled offspring. S-monomorphy occurred when assortative mating was high in the S-morph (_aS/dS_ > 1.7) but low in the L-morph (Fig. 4a). Under this particular

scenario, the genotypes of S-individuals were primarily _SS_ (Fig. 4b, c). DISCUSSION This study provides additional insight into the nature and maintenance of stigma-height dimorphism in

_Narcissus_. The polymorphism in _N. assoanus_ and _N. dubius_ differs from distyly because neither species possesses reciprocal herkogamy, pollen heteromorphisms or heteromorphic

incompatibility. These facts support the argument that the dimorphism is fundamentally distinct from heterostyly (Baker et al., 2000). Yet the stigma-height dimorphism is manifested quite

differently in the two _Narcissus_ species because of features of their floral biology that influence the mating systems of populations. Here we discuss how contrasting physiological and

morphological traits in _N. assoanus_ and _N. dubius_ affect mating and fertility and result in the patterns of morph-frequency variation observed in populations of the two species in SW

France. COMPATIBILITY STATUS OF _NARCISSUS ASSOANUS_ AND _N. DUBIUS_ Our controlled glasshouse pollinations indicated that whereas _N. assoanus_ is moderately self-sterile, _N. dubius_ is

thoroughly self-compatible. Most _Narcissus_ species that have been examined experimentally have proved to be self-incompatible (Bateman, 1954; Dulberger, 1964; Barrett et al., 1996, 1997;

Sage et al., 1999), although several fully self-compatible species are reported (Herrera, 1995; Barrett et al., 1996). Despite the presence of stylar polymorphisms in _Narcissus_ there is no

evidence that any species in the genus possesses heteromorphic incompatibility. However, the class of incompatibility (gametophytic vs. sporophytic) and its genetic basis (single-locus vs.

multilocus) remain unclear. Studies of dimorphic _N. tazetta_ and trimorphic _N. triandrus_ indicate a late-acting self-incompatibility system in which self and cross pollen tubes grow at

equivalent rates and self-rejection occurs in the ovary (Bateman, 1954; Dulberger, 1964; Barrett et al., 1997; Sage et al., 1999). It is possible that _N. assoanus_ also possesses

late-acting incompatibility because, in common with these species, preliminary crosses have indicated that prior self-pollination of flowers 48 h before outcrossing results in a significant

reduction in fertility (A.M. Baker, J.D. Thompson & S.C.H. Barrett, unpubl. data). However, the reduced seed-set upon selfing could also arise from early acting inbreeding depression

(Seavey & Bawa, 1986; Husband & Schemske, 1996). Detailed investigations of pollen–pistil interactions and ovule and seed development would be required to confirm this (e.g. see Sage

et al., 1999). All three populations of _N. assoanus_ responded similarly to the pollination treatments. There was considerable variation among plants in their response to self-pollination,

with some strongly self-sterile and others in which self-sterility was only partially expressed. A few individuals were detected that set equivalent amounts of seed from both self- and

cross-pollinations. There was no evidence that the style morphs differed in the overall strength of self-sterility that might influence selfing rates. Data on mating patterns in natural

populations were consistent with this finding because no differences in outcrossing rate between style morphs were observed (see below). In _N. dubius_, most individuals set abundant seed on

self-pollination. Self-compatibility in this species may have arisen through selection of individuals in ancestral populations with weak expression of self-sterility similar to that

observed in _N. assoanus_. Uncertain pollinator service could explain the self-compatible status of this early spring-flowering species. _Narcissus longispathus_, another early flowering

species, is also highly self-compatible (Herrera, 1995), and early flowering has often been invoked to explain the evolution of increased levels of self-fertilization (Lloyd, 1965; Jain,

1976). An unexpected feature of the crossing data for _N. assoanus_ was the significantly lower fertility of the L-morph in comparison with the S-morph (Fig. 1). On average, plants of the

L-morph set 33% less seed and 31% fewer fruit from cross-pollinations than those of the S-morph. This pattern was evident in all three populations used in the crossing programme (data not

shown) in two separate years. Yet our measurements of the natural fertility of six _N. assoanus_ populations, including one of the three populations used in glasshouse pollinations, failed

to detect significant morph-specific differences in female fertility. It seems unlikely that this result is caused by sampling effects associated with the particular plants of the L-morph

used in the glasshouse studies as sample sizes were generally large. Also, the contrasting patterns of fertility cannot result from ovule discounting because of the influence of different

degrees of herkogamy on autonomous self-pollination (see Barrett et al., 1996; Baker et al., 2000). All flowers used in hand-pollinations were emasculated prior to being cross-pollinated. It

is possible that environmental conditions in the glasshouse influenced the fertility of the style morphs differently; for example, if temperature and humidity conditions were suboptimal for

pollen–pistil interactions, fewer pollen tubes may have reached receptive ovules in the L-morph in comparison with the S-morph because of differences between the morphs in style length. Of

relevance to this interpretation is the finding that the time taken for pollen tubes to reach ovules is longest in the L-morph and shortest in the S-morph in tristylous _N. triandrus_ (Sage

et al., 1999). MATERNAL FITNESS COMPONENTS IN NATURAL POPULATIONS Style-morph ratios in populations of _Narcissus_ species are likely to be more sensitive to morph-specific differences in

fitness compared with species in which disassortative mating is guaranteed because of heteromorphic incompatibility. We therefore sought to establish whether differences in maternal fitness

components of the style morphs could explain the wide ranges of population morph frequencies that occur in _N. assoanus_ and _N. dubius_. However, our measurements of female fertility and

outcrossing rate in natural populations failed to detect differences between the style morphs. Thus it is unlikely that these features of the reproductive biology are of any significance in

accounting for the patterns of morph-ratio variation previously documented (Baker et al., 2000). Although occasional differences between morphs within particular populations were sometimes

detected, there was no evidence of any clear trends that could account for the L-biased ratios that commonly occur. Within populations of _N. assoanus_ levels of fruit- and seed-set of the

style morphs were similar, despite striking variation among years. Outcrossing rates of the morphs were near 1.0 in all populations, indicating that despite the potential for high levels of

autonomous self-pollination in the L-morph; self-sterility apparently prevents both increased ovule discounting and selfing in this morph. How this is achieved is by no means clear. Previous

studies demonstrated that prior selfing can reduce fertility in this and other _Narcissus_ species (Dulberger, 1964; Barrett et al., 1997; A.M. Baker, J.D. Thompson & S.C.H. Barrett,

unpubl. data), leading us to expect that autonomous self-pollination might result in reduced female fertility in the L-morph in comparison with the S-morph. This could occur if autonomous

self-pollination renders ovules unreceptive prior to the arrival of outcrossed pollen. This expectation was not borne out, suggesting that either sufficient outcross pollen is delivered to

L-stigmas by pollinators before autodeposition occurs, or that postpollination mechanisms act to favour outcross fertilizations and hence maintain fertility. Although our sampling of _N.

dubius_ was more limited, there were no consistent fertility differences between the style morphs that seem likely to account for the strongly L-biased morph ratios observed in this species.

In one population (StB) in 1996, the L-morph set 68% more seed than the S-morph. If this difference were to occur regularly, it could influence the dynamics of morph frequencies in this

population. However, in 1998, comparisons of the fertility of style morphs in this population failed to detect the pattern observed in 1996, so it is not clear how often such an effect

occurs. Estimates of outcrossing in the three dimorphic populations that were examined also failed to reveal significant style morph effects, although the power to detect small differences

in mating was low because of the limited number of allozyme loci (two) available for the estimates. Overall, _N. dubius_ exhibited a mixed-mating system with an average of 42% of seed

arising from self-fertilization. Higher selfing in _N. dubius_, compared to _N. assoanus_, was not unexpected given the self-compatible status and the possession of multiflowered

inflorescences. Even the relatively small floral displays found in _N. dubius_ (one to seven flowers per inflorescence) provide opportunities for geitonogamy that are not possible in most

_N. assoanus_ plants, which are largely solitary-flowered in SW France. The occurrence of several inflorescences per plant in _N. dubius_ because of bulb fragmentation also increases the

likelihood of geitonogamous selfing. POLLEN DISPERSAL AND ITS INFLUENCE ON MATING PATTERNS Our failure to detect differences in maternal fitness components between the style morphs of _N.

assoanus_ and _N. dubius_ motivated us to consider the influence of pollen dispersal on mating patterns. Unfortunately, measurement of the key parameters required to understand the

relationships between floral morphology, pollen dispersal and mating was hampered by the absence of pollen-size heteromorphism in _Narcissus_ (Baker et al., 2000), and a lack of suitable

genetic markers for estimating pollen transfer and levels of assortative and disassortative mating. Because of these difficulties, we chose to adopt a theoretical approach by developing a

simple genetic model that explored the relationships between mating patterns and style-morph ratios. The model demonstrated that stigma-height dimorphism will always be maintained when

levels of disassortative mating are greater than assortative mating, and that morph-specific differences in these mating parameters give rise to populations with biased style-morph ratios.

These findings imply that the commonly observed L-biased morph ratios in _Narcissus_ spp. result from higher levels of assortative mating in the L- vs. the S-morph. How likely is this to

occur? Several lines of evidence support the view that assortative mating will be more frequent in the L-morph in comparison to the S-morph. Because most monomorphic species of _Narcissus_

have sex organs in a similar position to the L-morph it seems reasonable to assume that effective pollen transfer between plants with this morphology is generally adaptive. The common

occurrence of populations monomorphic for the L-morph, but not the S-morph, among dimorphic _Narcissus_ species is consistent with this view (Barrett et al., 1996; Baker et al., 2000). Thus,

in dimorphic populations, matings between plants of the L-morph should be common. However, although stigmas of the L-morph correspond in height to upper-level anthers of both morphs,

stigmas of the S-morph are situated well below the lower-level anthers, particularly those of the S-morph (Baker et al., 2000). The disparity in organ height may reduce the precision of

intramorph pollinations in the S-morph. Indeed, experimental studies of heterostylous plants have demonstrated that pollen transfer between anthers and stigmas of equivalent height occurs

much more often than between sex organs of dissimilar position (Ganders, 1974; Barrett & Glover, 1985; Kohn & Barrett, 1992; Lloyd & Webb, 1992). Therefore it seems likely that

the high degree of herkogamy in the S-morph, compared to the L-morph, reduces the likelihood of assortative mating in this morph. According to this interpretation, most matings in the

S-morph are disassortative, whereas a mixture of assortative and disassortative mating is likely to occur in the L-morph. As our simulations demonstrate, this mating pattern results in

populations with L-biased morph ratios or populations fixed for the L-morph. This mating pattern also predicts that plants of the S-morph will largely be of the _Ss_ genotype, a situation

consistent with genetic data obtained from _N. tazetta_ (Dulberger, 1964; see Baker et al., 2000). In conclusion, populations of _N. assoanus_ and _N. dubius_ exhibit a continuum of

style-morph frequencies from isoplethy (1:1) to populations fixed for the L-morph. _Narcissus assoanus_ populations are always dimorphic and some occur at the isoplethic end of the

continuum, whereas populations of _N. dubius_ are strongly L-biased and occasionally fixed for this morph. We interpret this variation as resulting from differences between the two species

in mating patterns, particularly levels of assortative and disassortative mating. Self-sterility in _N. assoanus_ favours the maintenance of stigma-height dimorphism because the vast

majority of matings arise from outcrossing, and in many populations, a sizeable fraction must arise from crosses between the style morphs. In contrast, in _N. dubius_, disassortative mating

appears to be more difficult to achieve and self-compatibility may have aided secondary reversion to stylar monomorphism in some populations through founder events. These contrasting

influences on style-morph ratios in _Narcissus_ spp. serve to illustrate the complex dynamics that can occur when morphological and physiological traits are not genetically associated as in

most heterostylous species. Because of this, stigma-height polymorphisms provide excellent opportunities to investigate natural selection on simply inherited floral traits without the

confounding effects of heteromorphic incompatibility. REFERENCES * Arroyo, J. and Dafni, A. (1995). Variation in habitat, season, flower traits, and pollinators in dimorphic _Narcissus

tazetta_ L. (Amaryllidaceae) in Israel. _New Phytol_, 129: 135–145. Article  Google Scholar  * Baker, A. M., Thompson, J. D. and Barrett, S. C. H. (2000). Evolution and maintenance of

stigma-height dimorphism in _Narcissus_ I. Floral variation and style-morph ratios. _Heredity_. 84: in press. Article  Google Scholar  * Barrett, S. C. H. (ed.) (1992). _Evolution and

Function of Heterostyly_. Springer-Verlag, Berlin. Book  Google Scholar  * Barrett, S. C. H. and Glover, D. E. (1985). On the Darwinian hypothesis of the adaptive significance of tristyly.

_Evolution_ 39: 766–774. Article  Google Scholar  * Barrett, S. C. H., Brown, A. H. D. and Shore, J. S. (1987). Disassortative mating in tristylous _Eichhornia paniculata_ (Spreng.) Solms

(Pontederiaceae). _Heredity_ 58: 49–55. Article  Google Scholar  * Barrett, S. C. H., Morgan, M. T. and Husband, B. C. (1989). The dissolution of a complex genetic polymorphism: the

evolution of self-fertilization in tristylous _Eichhornia paniculata_ (Pontederiaceae). _Evolution_ 43: 1398–1416. Article  Google Scholar  * Barrett, S. C. H., Lloyd, D. G. and Arroyo, J.

(1996). Stylar polymorphisms and the evolution of heterostyly in _Narcissus_ (Amaryllidaceae). In: Lloyd, D. G. and Barrett, S. C. H. (eds) _Floral Biology. Studies on Floral Evolution in

Animal-Pollinated Plants_ pp. 339–376. Chapman & Hall, New York. Google Scholar  * Barrett, S. C. H., Cole, W. W., Arroyo, J., Cruzan, M. B. and Lloyd, D. G. (1997). Sexual polymorphisms

in _Narcissus triandrus_ (Amaryllidaceae): is this species tristylous? _Heredity_ 78: 135–145. Article  Google Scholar  * Bateman, A. J. (1954). The genetics of _Narcissus_ I. Sterility.

In: _Daffodil and Tulip Yearbook 19_ pp. 23–29. Royal Horticulture Society, London. Google Scholar  * Bodmer, W. F. (1960). Genetics of homostyly in populations of _Primula vulgaris_. _Phil

Trans R Soc B_, 242: 517–549. Article  Google Scholar  * Charlesworth, D. (1979). The evolution and breakdown of tristyly. _Evolution_ 33: 486–498. Article  Google Scholar  * Charlesworth,

D. and Charlesworth, B. (1979). A model for the evolution of distyly. _Am Nat_, 114: 467–498. Article  Google Scholar  * Crosby, J. L. (1949). Selection of an unfavourable gene complex.

_Evolution_, 3: 212–230. Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * Darwin, C. (1877). _The Different Forms of Flowers on Plants of the Same Species Reprinted in 1986_. University of Chicago Press,

Chicago, IL. Google Scholar  * Dulberger, R. (1964). Floral dimorphism and self-incompatibility in _Narcissus tazetta_ L. _Evolution_, 18: 361–363. Article  Google Scholar  * Eckert, C. G.

and Barrett, S. C. H. (1994). Post-pollination mechanisms and the maintenance of outcrossing in self-compatible, tristylous, _Decodon verticillatus_ (Lythraceae). _Heredity_, 72: 396–411.

Article  Google Scholar  * Ganders, F. R. (1974). Disassortative pollination in the distylous plant _Jepsonia heterandra_. _Can J Bot_, 52: 2401–2406. Article  Google Scholar  * Ganders, F.

R. (1975). Mating patterns in self-compatible distylous populations of _Amsinckia_ (Boraginaceae). _Can J Bot_, 53: 773–779. Article  Google Scholar  * Herrera, C. M. (1995). Floral biology,

microclimate, and pollination by ectothermic bees in an early-blooming herb. _Ecology_, 76: 218–228. Article  Google Scholar  * Heuch, I. (1979). Equilibrium populations of heterostylous

plants. _Theor Pop Biol_, 15: 43–57. Article  Google Scholar  * Husband, B. C. and Schemske, D. W. (1996). Evolution of the magnitude and timing of inbreeding depression in plants.

_Evolution_ 50: 54–70. Article  Google Scholar  * Jain, S. K. (1976). The evolution of inbreeding in plants. _Ann Rev Ecol Syst_, 7: 69–95. Article  Google Scholar  * Kohn, J. R. and

Barrett, S. C. H. (1992). Experimental studies on the functional significance of heterostyly. _Evolution_, 46: 43–55. Article  Google Scholar  * Lloyd, D. G. (1965). Evolution of

self-compatibility and racial differentiation in _Leavenworthia_ (Cruciferae). _Contr Gray Herb_, 195: 3–133. Google Scholar  * Lloyd, D. G. and Webb, C. J. (1992). The selection of

heterostyly. In: Barrett, S. C. H. (ed.) _Evolution and Function of Heterostyly_ pp. 179–207. Springer-Verlag, Berlin. Chapter  Google Scholar  * Ritland, K. (1990). A series of Fortran

computer programs for estimating plant mating systems. _J Hered_, 81: 235–237. Article  Google Scholar  * Sage, T. L., Strumas, F., Cole, W. W. and Barrett, S. C. H. (1999). Differential

ovule development following self- and cross-pollination: the basis of self-sterility in _Narcissus triandrus_ (Amaryllidaceae). _Am J Bot_, 86: 855–870. Article  CAS  Google Scholar  * SAS

(1994). JMP _ Users Guide_ version 3.0.2. SAS Institute, Cary, NC. * Seavey, S. R. and Bawa, K. S. (1986). Late-acting self-incompatibility in angiosperms. _Bot Rev_, 52: 195–219. Article 

Google Scholar  * Shore, J. S. and Barrett, S. C. H. (1987). Inheritance of floral and isozyme polymorphisms in _Turnera ulmifolia_ L. _J Hered_ 78: 44–48. Article  CAS  Google Scholar  *

Sokal, R. R. and Rohlf, F. J. (1995). _Biometry_ 3rd edn. W. H. Freeman & Co., San Francisco, CA. Google Scholar  * Wendel, J. F. and Weeden, N. F. (1989). Visualization and

interpretation of plant isozymes. In: Soltis, D. E. and Soltis, P. S. (eds) _Isozymes in Plant Biology_ pp. 5–45. Dioscorides Press, Portland, OR. Chapter  Google Scholar  Download

references ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We thank Lawrence Harder and Anne Worley for valuable discussion and assistance in the field; Peter Taylor, Chris Eckert, Linley Jesson and Bill Cole for advice

in the development of the mating model and comments on the manuscript; and Stephen Wright for assistance in seed counting. This work was funded by an operating grant from the Natural

Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC) to S.C.H.B. and a grant from CNRS to J.D.T. A.M.B. was supported by graduate scholarships from NSERC and the Ontario government.

AUTHOR INFORMATION AUTHORS AND AFFILIATIONS * Department of Botany, University of Toronto, 25 Willcocks Street, Toronto, M5S 3B2, Ontario, Canada Angela M Baker & Spencer C H Barrett *

Centre d’Ecologie Fonctionnelle et Evolutive, CNRS, 1919 Route de Mende, Montpellier, Cedex 5, 34293, France John D Thompson Authors * Angela M Baker View author publications You can also

search for this author inPubMed Google Scholar * John D Thompson View author publications You can also search for this author inPubMed Google Scholar * Spencer C H Barrett View author

publications You can also search for this author inPubMed Google Scholar CORRESPONDING AUTHOR Correspondence to Angela M Baker. RIGHTS AND PERMISSIONS Reprints and permissions ABOUT THIS

ARTICLE CITE THIS ARTICLE Baker, A., Thompson, J. & Barrett, S. Evolution and maintenance of stigma-height dimorphism in _Narcissus_. II. Fitness comparisons between style morphs.

_Heredity_ 84, 514–524 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-2540.2000.00686.x Download citation * Received: 25 May 1999 * Accepted: 04 October 1999 * Published: 01 May 2000 * Issue Date:

01 May 2000 * DOI: https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-2540.2000.00686.x SHARE THIS ARTICLE Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content: Get shareable link Sorry, a

shareable link is not currently available for this article. Copy to clipboard Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative KEYWORDS * disassortative mating * female

fertilty * mating system * plant sexual polymorphism * self-sterility * stigma-height dimorphism